 Juan Carlos Lopez |
 Andy Marshall |
X-ray crystallography has long been the go-to workhorse for providing atomic structures of drugs interacting with their protein targets. Increasingly, those static snapshots are being complemented by readouts from experimental analytical tools based on nucleic magnetic resonance (NMR) spectroscopy and cryoelectron microscopy (cryo-EM), offering drug developers a broader window into proteins as dynamic, breathing molecules. This is spurring a raft of new service provider startups, including AIffinity (Brno-Medlánky, Czech Republic), NexMR (Zürich, Switzlerand), CryoCloud (Utrecht), and Intellicule (West Lafayette, IN), all of which aim to supply drug-discovery teams with state-of-the-art platforms providing structural data with rapid turnaround times and low cost.
As many of the most compelling ‘undruggable’ targets are renowned shape shifters — aggregation-prone proteins like Tau, amyloid precursor protein (APP) or huntingtin in neurodegenerative diseases, or transcription factors like P53, KRAS and c-MYC in oncology — a lot of therapeutic startup activity has recently focused around so-called ‘intrinsically disordered proteins’ (IDPs). The ability to attain markedly different conformations under different conditions allows IDPs not only to play moonlighting roles or serve as hubs in signaling networks, but also to localize into liquid- phase condensates (or membrane-less organelles — attributes that make them acutely sensitive to mutations that can compromise specificity and lead to nonspecific binding, resulting in toxicity and disease.
As IDPs frequently resist attack by conventional drug discovery approaches, a slew of startups has sprung up to try to go after this target class, many using new structural techniques. These include Peptone (London, UK), Dewpoint Therapeutics (Boston, MA), brainQR Therapeutics (Göttingen, Germany), and Kodiform Therapeutics (Oxford, UK). Just last month, Topos Bio secured a $10.5 million seed round to “tackle ‘undruggable’ proteins driving Alzheimer’s and cancer”. Dewpoint also just announced it has dosed its first patient in a phase 1/2a trial of its lead beta-catenin program in gastric cancer and elected its MYC development candidate to take forward.
An important postscript to the startup activity targeting undruggable IDPs is that more conventional ‘druggable’ target classes, like tyrosine kinases, may also represent a fruitful hunting ground for dynamic conformational states that may have been missed by traditional crystallographic approaches. Given that conventional drug targets have relatively well-trodden clinical and commercial development paths, they may also represent simpler starting points and testing grounds for commercial programs aiming to apply the new analytical approaches to support medicinal chemistry programs around validated targets.
In a paper recently published in Science, the team of Charalampos (Babis) Kalodimos at St. Jude Children’s Research Hospital use high-resolution NMR spectroscopy to gain structural insight into how SRC family tyrosine kinases (Src, Hck, and Lck) achieve processive phosphorylation of multisite substrates.
|
|
The SRC enzyme family is essential for rapid and coordinated signaling in processes such as cell migration and T-cell activation. In addition, SRC family kinases are frequently overexpressed in tumors, contributing to the activation not only of multiple scaffold or signaling proteins, such as receptor tyrosine kinases (e.g., EGFR, FGFR, PDGFR or IGF1R), but also of downstream effectors (e.g., MAPKs, FAK, paxillin, p130Cas, ELMO1 and RAC1). Although there are approved drugs like the multikinase inhibitor Sprycel (dasatinib) that bind the SRC active site, these drugs have such extensive off-target and adverse side effects that there is a pressing need for new paths to more-selective SRC inhibitors.
SRC enzymes share a conserved domain organization, with a disordered N-tail, a tandem SH3–SH2 module, a kinase domain, and a disordered C-tail. All can carry out processive phosphorylation — a phenomenon where the enzyme phosphorylates multiple residues in a substrate during a single encounter. Each of these catalytic cycles typically requires ATP binding, phosphate transfer and ADP release, and ADP release is often the rate-limiting step. So, a question that has long puzzled structural biologists is how ADP-release–constrained kinases achieve sufficiently rapid turnover to successfully perform their function.
Using NMR spectroscopy with cryogenic probes — which reduce electronic/thermal noise and increase sensitivity up to five-fold compared with room-temperature probes — the St. Jude team characterized the conformational ensemble of the Src kinase domain and identified three interconverting states: a predominant active state, a previously described inactive Src/CDK-like state, and a hitherto unknown low-populated intermediate state positioned linearly between the other two. Structural determination revealed that this intermediate state displays features that are distinct from the active and inactive states. Its activation loop is partially folded, the P-loop is displaced inward, and the αC helix is shifted upward. This conformation binds ADP poorly relative to the active and inactive states, suggesting that it facilitates nucleotide release.
|
|
Using mutational analyses, the researchers then confirmed the functional importance of this intermediate state. Variants that eliminated this intermediate state while stabilizing the active state showed slower ADP dissociation, reduced catalytic turnover and impaired processive phosphorylation of the multisite Src substrate p130Cas. Instead of generating a fully phosphorylated substrate in a single binding event, these mutants accumulated partially phosphorylated intermediates. Equivalent mutations in other kinases of the SRC family, Lck and Hck, similarly reduced catalytic efficiency and impaired multisite phosphorylation of their respective physiological substrates CD3ζ and ELMO1 in Jurkat cells. Furthermore, these mutations compromised cellular functions measured via in vitro assays, including T-cell activation using Lck-deficient Jurkat cells and migration of mouse embryo fibroblasts lacking Src, Yes and Fyn in the presence of fibronectin. These molecular and functional findings indicate that the intermediate state is evolutionarily conserved and essential for processive activity across the SRC family.
Mechanistically, the work establishes that rapid ADP release, enabled by transient sampling of a structurally constrained intermediate, is critical for sustaining catalytic turnover rates that exceed the speed of substrate dissociation. More broadly, it shows that kinase conformational landscapes are tuned not only for switching between active and inactive states, but also for optimizing specific kinetic steps within the catalytic cycle.
From a drug developer’s standpoint, because Sprycel and other inhibitors target the active or inactive conformations of the SRC active site, the identification of a low-populated, functionally indispensable intermediate suggests a completely new strategy to target tyrosine kinases: selectively stabilize or destabilize the intermediate state to fine-tune catalytic turnover and processivity rather than simply blocking activity. Targeting such transient conformations could enable more precise modulation of signaling output, potentially improving selectivity and reducing off-target effects in kinase-directed therapies.
We look forward to seeing how many more of these intermediate states are uncovered in other kinase targets and whether pharmacological inhibitors targeting this state have advantages over orthosteric or allosteric chemotypes that conventionally have been used to inhibit the kinase active site or lock it in an inactive conformation. What is clear is that ultrafast NMR measurements of binding and state behavior are a powerful differentiating tool for understanding kinase activity where static structures aren’t enough.
Next Phase Newsletter 